I - II *spoilers up to EP05* ANALYSIS of UMINEKO NO NAKU KORO NI EP01 : Legend of The Golden Witch (anime version) part 2

2nd green question frm I -I

"Did maria recieve any letter in EP05? Gotta check when re-reading ep05?"

No there was none, the first letter came after battler's discovery of the gold.

hmm wad does this say? In the content of the letter, it congratulates battler for solving the epitaph. That means its nt written way in advanced, it can only be written after erika's announce to the siblings about the discovery of the gold. So we can narrow down the possible people who is responsible for the letter.

Well lets leave that for EP05 discussion, woah like damn far away haha.

==========================================

Topic 2: Rudolf's own death prediction?

Firstly, when he meant that, he might die. Did he mean,

1) imma die, cos XYZ, therefore imma tell u guys while i can
2) damn there is something i wanna tell u guys. Dun kill me after u know the truth xD

Initially wad i tot was scenario 1, but apparently in ep05, he said that its about battler's birth, and he wants to talk about it with the whole family.

Frm the way Rudolf talks, as well as kyrie and battler, im sure he could hav meant jokingly.

"Dun kill me. Battler, actually, Kyrie is ur real mom / Asuma is nt ur mom."

Something liddat. Neways i gt a feeling that ryukishi07 will surprise us with a truth that nobody expected.

Cos since if its scenario 1, im sure any dude will asap tell battler or kyrie wadeva he wanted to say if he felt that his live was seriously in danger.

 So doesnt this means that Rudolf's proclamation doesnt help? !@#$EWFDSF

=============================

Topic 3 : Wad effect would there be on natsuhi upon the knowledge of the existance of the hidden gold?

Cos we know that there are several conditions that is constant. Like since kinzo is always dead before the game, the family must know about it, GENJI at least, so its almost certain that the EP05 natsuhi is present in all the episodes, unless on such occasions that, some1 else discovered kinzo's death first, hide the truth, got some1 else to pretend as him, handle the corpse.  that would be a tough job.

But in EP05, i think natsuhi is unaware of the existance of the gold, despite believing in the power of the witch =.=.

But wad about Krauss? Is it a constant that he had that single one winged eagle gold ingot? I believe that we can assume that for now. Cos if we use the, "letter is done by natsuhi/krauss" theory, if krauss KNEW that the gold existed, that would allow him to conjure a plan of such. Normally it wouldn cross any1's mind to fake a letter frm a "witch" blah blah blah......

But cos he was aware that the GOLD DOES EXIST, regardless of who it came frm, only den was he able to think of a plan of such.

Cos the letter dun jus distract the siblings frm krauss. if they actually find the gold, it will even save all of them frm their problems.

It doesnt jus solve his problem, it even makes him richer.

Therefore, any1 with the knowledge of the existence of the gold, is a suspect for the one responsible for the letter.

===============================================================

Topic 4: The Head's Ring

How was kinzo's body 'settled'? Will they bury the ring with him? Will they keep it? Will Krauss keep it since he is the heir?

When maria takes out the letter, every1 is shocked. But no1 was shock to the extent of OVER 9000!!!!!!!!!, cos they tot that the ring was buried with kinzo, or worst still, supposedly in their possession. They didn react that way. That means thief is out of the picture.

Krauss and natsuhi and the servants and nanjo all didn react like, USO DA! ITS ABSOLUTELY IMPOSSIBLE, THERE IS NO ARGUMENT! IN FACT I'LL SHOW U. THE RING IS HERE! oh, oops.

Therefore, i think i can almost conclude that its absolutely some1 with the knowledge of the existence of the gold, responsible for the letter.

=======================================


Hmm den where is Beatrice in the picture? How to allow her to exist?

I - I *spoilers up to EP05* ANALYSIS of UMINEKO NO NAKU KORO NI EP01 : Legend of The Golden Witch (anime version) part 1

He has already announce that all the clues needed to solve the entire mystery is provided, now its time to defeat ryukishi07.

My plan now is to rewatch ep 01 to 04 via anime, den re-read the sound novel frm ep05 to ep01.

Let it begin.
======================================
Topic 1: beatrice's letter?

Question 1: Who gave maria the letter?

Possible suspects : Genji, nanjo, natsuhi, more?
Impossible suspects :
To be reinforced with facts when reading SN.
======================================
Question 2: Wad is the purpose of the letter?

I guess we gotta try and imagine What effects/differences would the letter create? Compare with how things will be

like if the letter didn appear.

Den there another part of the letter, the head's seal on the wax, does this means it is absolutely done by krauss' family / servants / nanjo ; people who know that kinzo is dead.

Did maria recieve any letter in EP05? Gotta check when re-reading ep05

So for the time being we assume that its the 'people who know that kinzo is dead', or at least some or one of them,

who is responsible for the letter, so wad effect did they expect to create, wad is the motive?

If there was no letter....
The 3 younger siblings will try to get some $$$ frm krauss, with their talks about recognising him as the head blah blah blah. As shown in ep01, he manage to fight them off. Den in some other ep i forgot which 1, kyrie talk about the responsibiliy of the caretaker of the head blah blah blah. Although those games are parallel worlds, this represent possibilities. Neways Which implies that their plan, 'missing Kinzo', is nt foolproof, they must have taken that into consideration.

In that situation, to be exact, at that moment, it has to be proven that kinzo still exist, is the motive of the younger siblings. Cos they arent waiting for 7 years later, they wan to expose krauss now and threathen him to giving them the money that all 3 of them need urgently.

.
.
.
.
.
.

So how will the witch's letter help? If we assume that its the 'people who know that kinzo is dead' who are behind the letter.

A distraction? To divert the topic of whether kinzo is dead or not, or even destroy the idea?

The letter announce to every that, Beatrice, exist. She call herself alchemist-adviser of the house. Y nt jus
witch? I wonder how its writen in jap.

And the letter says that, '...but, today, Kinzo-sama sentenced the end of that contract. '

Ah isnt that prove that Kinzo is alive?

And den, 'As for that condition, he will return me all the gold by the end of the contract. And as an interest, I can accept everything of the Ushiromiya family.'

With that, doesnt it makes the 3 siblings panic? The $$$ that they were eyeing for, snatched away under their nose.

'However, Kinzo-sama, in order to give a chance to leave the wealth and fortune to everyone, added a special clause. Only when that clause is satisfied, I’ll eternally lose my right to collect the gold and the interest.” 'And if any1 can solve the riddle, and find the GOLD, beatrice will have to give up the rights to the shits of ushiromiya family.....

.
.
.
.
.

WHO CARES ABOUT USHIROMIYA IF WE FIND 10 TONS OF GOLD?

.
.
.
.

I think this is a wonder plan that works for krauss and natsuhi.

.
.
.
.
.
.

But umineko is not just a mystery novel. And i am a supporter of magic. How to put beatrice into the picture? How does she exist and wad is her motives?

Now i understand how battler feels when he tries to explain the murders logically; denying magic and therefore proposing that a human is responsible for the crimes, but dun wan suspect any of the other 17 people on the island. Terrible feeling, dunno if i should jus drop that line of thought, or change it to suit to my liking, but find it impossible to do so.

Ah den thats when Ange comes into the picture, and tell battler that there is no need care about who being the culprit. Even if its Shannon den so be it. cos she wants her onii-chan to end this stupid game go home asap. I think its like when subduing some dude who punched u for no reason earlier, u decide to jus restrict his movements and be careful not to hurt him cos later he cannot go to work tml. lol shitz analogy? That being said, its magic that allow ange to travel to this world and help her brother. In that sense its obvious that she recognise magic. But in this case battler gotta end this game to return to ange, so jus go ahead and deny magic, beatrice's magic to be exact. It might be impossible for my right eye to see random rainbows, but who says its impossible for gucci's pol lubricated eye?

Den we have erika, who represent the readers, we see this murder case as an interesting mystery for us to solve. There is no need to be sad for the characters who die, as it is nessesary for the mystery novel. With no regard for any consequeces of any actions, cos we exist outside of the gameboard.

Shit i drifted quite far liao. Taking a break frm this brainstorm.

===============================================

The letter 'written' by some1 with the knowledge of kinzo's death, it is written with the intention to help assist in the cover up of kinzo's death.

Find out possible and impossible suspects for giving maria the letter.